If you’re looking for affordable homes, peaceful lakefront views, and small-town charm tucked between Winter Haven and Bartow—Eagle Lake is the kind of place that might just surprise you. It’s quiet, it’s cozy, and it’s perfectly located for those who want space to breathe without losing access to nearby city conveniences.
Whether you’re a first-time buyer, downsizing into a simpler lifestyle, or searching for a new construction home off the beaten path, Eagle Lake offers scenic surroundings, a close-knit community, and room to grow.
Eagle Lake is located in central Polk County, just a few miles southeast of Winter Haven and west of Bartow. It’s surrounded by—you guessed it—lakes! Including the town’s namesake, Eagle Lake, and nearby Lake McLeod and Lake Eloise.
To Winter Haven: 10–15 minutes
To Bartow: 15 minutes
To Lakeland: 30–35 minutes
To Tampa or Orlando: About 1 hour each
To LEGOLAND Florida: 15 minutes
With quick access to US-17 and SR-540, you’re never far from shopping, dining, medical care, or the next weekend adventure.
Eagle Lake is one of those Florida towns where life moves just a little slower—and that’s exactly the appeal. It’s small, safe, and scenic, with a growing number of new construction communities popping up alongside longtime family homes.
Residents love the tight-knit feel, open skies, and water views, and the town’s lower price point is attracting more first-time homebuyers and retirees looking for peace without HOA headaches.
While Eagle Lake is a smaller city, it’s got all the essentials—and plenty of charm to go with it. You’ll find:
Public lake access and boat ramps on Eagle Lake and nearby lakes
Parks, playgrounds, and walking trails
Community events and family-friendly festivals
Quick access to grocery stores, gas, and restaurants in Winter Haven or Bartow
New subdivisions with modern homes and community green space
Plus, if you’re looking for more dining, retail, or entertainment, Downtown Winter Haven is just down the road.
Eagle Lake is served by the Polk County School District, and several schools nearby have a strong reputation for community involvement and student support.
Local and nearby school options include:
Pinewood Elementary School
Lake Region High School – A larger campus just minutes away
Chain of Lakes Collegiate High School – A dual-enrollment program for motivated high schoolers
Gause Academy of Leadership – Offers alternative programs and technical education
Polk State College – Winter Haven campus – Just a short drive for higher education
Families love the access to both neighborhood schools and charter/magnet options in nearby Winter Haven.
With its lakeside setting and sunny weather, Eagle Lake is an ideal place to enjoy the outdoors year-round.
Local favorites include:
Eagle Lake Park – With a playground, walking trail, and beautiful views of the water
Lake McLeod – Popular for boating, kayaking, and quiet fishing days
Sertoma Park – A peaceful space for walks and family picnics
LEGOLAND Florida Resort – Just 15 minutes away, perfect for weekend fun with kids or visiting guests
Nearby trails, preserves, and nature spots throughout central Polk County
Whether you’re casting a line at sunrise or just enjoying the stillness of the lake from your back porch, Eagle Lake is made for nature lovers.
Eagle Lake is gaining attention for its affordable homes, new construction, and lakeside lifestyle. The market is ideal for first-time buyers, investors, and anyone seeking value close to Winter Haven and Bartow.
Median Home Price: Around $295,000 as of early 2025
Time on Market: 30–40 days for well-priced listings
New Construction: Growing fast, especially south of Eagle Lake and near US-17
Rental Market: Modest but steady, with rents averaging $1,600–$2,100/month
It’s a great place to buy more home for less, especially compared to nearby cities like Lakeland or Orlando suburbs.
Eagle Lake homes offer variety without the high price tag:
Starter homes and smaller ranch-style houses range from $230K–$300K, often with no HOA
New construction homes in developing neighborhoods are typically priced from $300K–$400K with modern layouts and energy-efficient features
Lakeside or lakeview homes can range from $375K–$550K+, depending on size and location
Vacant lots and buildable land are still available in some areas, starting from $40K–$100K+, depending on lake access or zoning
Whether you’re building, investing, or just looking for a simpler lifestyle, Eagle Lake offers affordable opportunity with scenic rewards.
If you’re craving quiet mornings, lake breezes, and a laid-back lifestyle with room to grow, Eagle Lake might just be Polk County’s best-kept secret. From first homes to final chapters, this peaceful town is ready to welcome you.
Let’s find the perfect spot in Eagle Lake to match your lifestyle. Click here to start your search or schedule a chat with a local expert who knows the neighborhoods, the builders, and the best buys on and off the lake.
What’s Next for Two Rivers? Golf, Growth & Lifestyle Expansion
Which Village in Two Rivers Fits Your Lifestyle?
Which Village in Two Rivers Fits Your Lifestyle?
Why Two Rivers is Zephyrhills’ most sought after new home community?
Discover Two Rivers in Zephyrhills—an 1,800-acre master-planned community offering new construction homes, scenic trails, resort-style amenities, and a short commute to Tampa. With villages designed for every stage of life, from first-time buyers to forever homes, Two Rivers is where lifestyle meets location. Explore your perfect fit in this nature-connected, amenity-rich neighborhood today.
Carla Goddard
Team Lead
License Number SL3392494
Broker Number BO2031053
813-716-4498
267511 SR 56
Wesley Chapel FL
Join our monthly newsletter for market updates, news from our community and more!
I agree to be contacted by Tampa Bay New Home Finders via call, email, and text. To opt out, you can reply ‘stop’ at any time or click the unsubscribe link in the emails. Message and data rates may apply. Privacy Policy
